Illustrative example · synthetic data · not a client engagement. The company, people, dates and references below are invented to show how we think. No customer is described.
[ Worked example ]
From a risk question to a lesson
One small evidence gap, followed from the question that found it to the lesson that came out of it. This is a proposed way of showing our process, to test with buyers. It is not a claim that others lack it.
01 · Illustrative example · synthetic data · not a client engagement
Risk question
Asked by the assessor
Can the contractor show that only authorized people can reach the systems inside the agreed boundary?
Assessment objective: the contractor can show who has access, that each person is authorized, and that access is reviewed on a schedule.
02 · Illustrative example · synthetic data · not a client engagement
Evidence
Provided by the system owner
An export of user accounts dated for the review, and the access review record, if one exists.
Finding: three accounts belong to people who have left. No review record exists. Nothing else was examined, so this finding says nothing about the rest of the boundary.
03 · Illustrative example · synthetic data · not a client engagement
Decision
Decided by the contractor's IT manager, on VEI's recommendation
Disable the three accounts and start a quarterly access review with a named owner.
VEI recommended; the contractor decided. VEI did not make the change, because corrective changes are authorized by the system owner.
04 · Illustrative example · synthetic data · not a client engagement
Corrective task
Owned by the IT manager
Change request EX-014 (made-up reference): disable the three accounts; add a quarterly review with an owner and a due date.
Implementation record kept by the contractor: who changed what, and when.
05 · Illustrative example · synthetic data · not a client engagement
Retest
Reviewed by a different VEI practitioner than the one who found the gap
A new account export shows the three accounts disabled. The first review record exists and is signed by the named owner.
Result: partly verified. The second quarterly review is not yet due, so the repeating process is not yet shown.
06 · Illustrative example · synthetic data · not a client engagement
Lesson
Written for the contractor's own team
A one-time clean-up is not the same as a process. Evidence should show the task repeating.
Ask who owns each account, not only whether the account exists.
[ What remains unresolved ]
- A shared service account has no named owner. The contractor has not decided who owns it.
- The second review has not happened yet, so we cannot say the process works.
- Whether the control satisfies any particular requirement is a matter for the assessor and the agreed requirements. This example does not say it does.